Wednesday 20 January 2021

Pliny the Elder on Elephants (N.H. 8, 1-3)

 

One of the Latin authors who is but little read, is Pliny the Elder (AD 23/24 – 79), a prolific writer, but whose writings have not survived, except the Naturalis Historiae. This work is an immense encyclopaedia concerning all knowledge about the natural world, plants, animals, anthropology, minerals etc. which was at his disposal. He died in 79 AD while investigating the volcanic eruption of the Vesuvius, before he could complete and edit his encyclopaedia. What he wrote at that time as natural science is now outdated and mostly only of antiquarian interest. Still, for people with an antiquarian interest, there is a lot to enjoy and wonder about in his writings. Take for instance what he has to say about elephants. Of course we can smile about his assertions; especially that elephants have some awareness of religion, but what is interesting for a historian is the fact that non-human beings were credited with such feelings and so the Naturalis Historia has turned from a work about nature into a mirror for Roman mentality.

 Pliny the Elder, Naturalis Historiae Liber VIII, 1-3.

 1 Ad reliqua transeamus animalia et primum terrestria. Maximum est elephans proximumque humanis sensibus, quippe intellectus illis sermonis patrii et imperiorum obedientia, officiorum quae didicere memoria, amoris et gloriae voluptas, immo vero, quae etiam in homine rara, probitas, prudentia, aequitas, religio quoque siderum solisque ac lunae veneratio. 2 auctores sunt in Mauretaniae saltibus ad quendam amnem, cui nomen est Amilo, nitescente luna nova greges eorum descendere ibique se purificantes sollemniter aqua circumspergi atque ita salutato sidere in silvas reverti vitulorum fatigatos prae se ferentes. 3 alienae quoque religionis intellectu creduntur maria transituri non ante naves conscendere quam invitati rectoris iureiurando de reditu, visique sunt fessi aegritudine, quando et illas moles infestant morbi, herbas supini in caelum iacentes, veluti tellure precibus allegata. nam, quod docilitatem attinet, regem adorant, genua submittunt, coronas porrigunt. Indis arant minores, quos appellant nothos.

 ad reliquia: for the remainder (Book 7 is about anthropology)

primum: first of all

sermonis patria: the language of their country

imperium: command order

officium: duty, task

didicere = didicerunt (the memory of elephants is proverbial)

immo: yes indeed

rarus: rare

probitas –atis (f.): honesty

aequitas –atis (f.): fairness

auctores sunt: there are writers who etc. The following aci construction depends on an understood `dicentes’ or a similar word. Construct : nitescente luna nova greges eorum descendere in Mauretaniae saltibus ad quendam amnem, cui nomen est Amilo

nitisco: to begin to shine

grex gregis (f.) herd

Mauretania: modern Morocco

saltus –us (m.): forest, woodland

Amilo: it is uncertain which river is meant

circumspergo (-sparsi -sparsum) to sprinkle around (circumspargi is medial)

ita salutato sidere: abl.abs.

vitulus: male-calf

prae se ferentes: i.e. with their tusks and trunks

alienae quoque religionis intellectu: with their understanding for the religious feelings of others (alienae religionis probably refers to letting the helmsman (rector) swear (iusiuro) a save return (reditus -us), which implies a common reverence for oaths and religion)

transituri: about to cross over

conscendo conscendi conscensum: to climb, go aboard

invito: to request, summon (and of course also `to invite’, but the Latin verb has a broader range of meaning than its English heir). Here invito is constructed with the ablative: iusiurando an oath to be sworn

fessi aegriudine: exhausted by disease

quando et: since even

moles –is (f.): mass, enormity

infesto: to disturb, befall, infest

morbus, disease, illness

supinus: lying on the back

veluti tellure precibus allegata: (abl.abs.) as if the earth being adduced (for assistance) with their prayers (what Pliny wants to say is not quite clear, but I think he means that strewing herbs on the earth is a religious act for invoking assistance. Another possibility is that they want the earth to pray for them, so: adduced for its prayers)

docilitas – tatis (f.): aptness for being taught

regem: the king of Persia. Elephants were used in the Persian army, and what Pliny describes seems to be the lowering of elephants for making it easy to be mounted

genua submittunt: they lower their knees

porrigo porrexi porrectum: to offer, present

aro: to plough, use for ploughing (they were indeed used for ploughing)

minores: the Indian elephant is smaller than the African

nothus: bastard from a known father; a Greek word for which the Roman had no equivalent. PI have no idea where this information comes from, but it could be that one of the words for elephant (and there a quite a few in India) `naga’ was misunderstood.

 Philemon Holland, translator (1601): C. Plinius Secundus The Historie of the World.

 Of land beasts. The praise of Elephants: their wit and understanding.

 PASSE wee now to treat of other living creatures, and first of land beasts: among which, the Elephant is the greatest, and commeth neerest in wit and capacitie, to men: for they understand the language of that country wherein they are bred, they do whatsoever they are commaunded, they remember what duties they be taught, and withall take a pleasure and delight both in love and also in glorie: nay more than all this, they embrace goodnesse, honestie, prudence, and equitie, (rare qualities I may tell you to be found in men) and withall have in religious reverence (with a kind of devotion) not only the starres and planets, but the sunne and moone they also worship. And in very truth, writers there be who report thus much of them, That when the new moon beginneth to appeare fresh and bright, they come down by whole heards to a certaine river named Amelus, in the deserts and forrest of Mauritania, where after that they are washed and solemnly purified by sprinkling & dashing themselves all over with the water, and have saluted and adored after their manner that planet, they returne againe into the woods and chases, carrying before them their yong calves that be wearied and tired. Moreover, they are thought to have a sense and understanding of religion and conscience in others; for when they are to passe the seas into another countrey, they will not embarke before they be induced thereto by an oath of their governours and rulers, That they shall returne againe: and seen there have been divers of them, being enfeebled by sicknesse (for as bigge and huge as they be, subject they are to grievous maladies) to lie upon their backes, casting and flinging hearbs up toward heaven, as if they had procured and set the earth to pray for them. Now for their docilitie and aptnesse to learne any thing; the king they adore, they kneele before him, and offer unto him guirlands and chaplets of flowers and green hearbs. To conclude, the lesser sort of them, which they call Bastards, serve the Indians in good stead to care and plough their ground.



 Moghul miniature. Further details unknown.

 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_History_(Pliny)